Writing True-Crime (Part 1) by Barry Cummins

Writing.ie | Resources | Better Non-Fiction Guides | Getting Started in Non-Fiction | Researching Non-Fiction
buried secrets true-crime

Barry Cummins

Writing true-crime books is an important public service, writes the author of Buried Secrets, Barry Cummins, and anyone with a passion for justice and solving mysteries can try it.

I wrote my first book, Missing, in 2003. It wasn’t the original book I’d actually pitched to the publisher Gill. My original idea was to write a book solely on one murder case which was awaiting a verdict in a trial at Dublin’s Central Criminal Court. That case was the trial of John Crerar, charged with the cold-case murder of Phyllis Murphy, who had been abducted and murdered in 1979. Gill’s then publishing director Fergal Tobin said it was too risky to put all my eggs in one basket, with the book’s existence hinging on an upcoming jury verdict. A jury might fail to reach a verdict and a retrial might be scheduled, or if John Crerar was acquitted that might scupper my plans to write about the case.

Fergal instead pointed out what was staring me in the face, but which I hadn’t actually properly thought of. By that early stage of my career in journalism I was already reporting on many missing persons cases in my job as Crime Correspondent of Today FM. ‘Why not write a book about all the women who disappeared in the last decade,’ asked Fergal. And so Missing was conceived over a convivial lunch, and my true-crime book writing began.

Over the past twenty years I’ve written six true-crime books, and I’ve learned a few lessons along the way, which I’m happy to share. Take as much or as little from it as you please.

Anyone can write a true-crime book if they’ve the interest and drive.

Mostly it’s journalists who publish true-crime books, but former gardaí and forensic experts can also put pen to paper, or fingers to keyboard. However, it’s open to anyone to put their mind to it. If you know about a local murder in your area, or are someone who has survived a crime, or are someone who has been convicted of a crime – and are actually innocent – if you have a unique, compelling story to tell, the next true-crime book could be within your mind.

Go back to basics with research

The best form of research is face-to-face interviews – either on or off the record. There are so many things to learn about a crime from speaking with people directly affected by it, or who know the ‘inside story’. And, by meeting in person with someone, you can tell so much by their body language, their demeanour, their emotions. And sometimes it might not only be what they say, but what they don’t say, that can give you a steer on where to go next for further research and information.

There are also places to go for publicly available information, from the Birth, Deaths and Marriages Office, to the Coroner’s Offices around the country, to the National Archives which can hold, not only case files from the early to mid 1900s, but much more recent files too.

Beware of the Internet

While the internet can be a very useful tool in pointing you in the right direction, so much ‘fake news’ is now online it can be very hard to distinguish from truth. And treat AI with more than one degree of caution. I recently searched for my name and Richard Satchwell’s name, when I was writing Buried Secrets (about how Richard murdered his wife Tina) and the AI prompt which came back stated I was one of the detectives who had solved the case! One can only dream……

Don’t go crazy with Adjectives

Murder, kidnap, rape, abduction, armed robberies, one punch attacks, bomb attacks – so many types of crime are horrific. There is a tendency (and I sometimes suffer it) to use too many words to try and sum up just how horrific something might be. There is an attraction in using words like ‘atrocious’ ‘appalling’ ‘senseless’ ‘shameful’ ‘shocking’ to hammer home just how awful a particular crime might be. I’m not saying you shouldn’t use some emotive words to convey the truth, but sometimes ‘less is more.’ In my most recent book I outline in detail how a woman’s body lay buried under her own stairs for over six years.

That such indignity was done to Tina Satchwell by her husband is absolutely appalling and shocking, and many more things. But I tried to avoid too many adjectives in telling that story. Often the horror of a crime will speak for itself. It might be too cold and uncaring to completely avoid putting one’s own feelings into the narrative, but just be careful you don’t do it too much. Let the reader come their own conclusion. In as much as feels right for you, just stick to the facts.

The tense

The first five books I wrote were in the past tense. I was writing about crimes which had occurred in previous times. It’s the most common way of writing any form of book, not just true-crime. But in Buried Secrets, I found myself writing in the present, in the active voice. It was a different book to anything I’d written before. I was reliving my own experiences, my memories of many meetings with a man who turned out to be a killer.

The sections of the book which covered my memories became very much ‘present moment’. I then decided to write the complete book in the same way. It just felt right. If a crime is personal to you or your family or someone you know, it might also work to consider the present tense, active voice. It brings something alive in the writing process. It certainly did for me with Buried Secrets.

The victim(s)

I have written about dozens of people I never had the pleasure of meeting. Ordinary people whose names are now known because of extraordinary events, dare I say ‘horrific’ events which have befallen them. I never met Annie McCarrick or Jo Jo Dullard, or Deirdre Jacob. I have, however, come to know their families, and many other families whose loved ones have been murdered.

Some people are able to write about murder cases or other crimes and not put the victim at the centre of what they do. I feel differently, I can only speak for myself. When it comes to murder cases I operate a rule that ‘there but for the grace of God goes anyone of us.’ Through that rule I put victims right at the centre of what I write. I find that it leaves me, and hopefully the readers, with a sense of ‘I’d love to have met Annie McCarrick’ or whoever I’ve written about.

(c) Barry Cummins

Read Part 2 of this article by Barry Cummins on writing true-crime here.

About Buried Secrets by Barry Cummins:

buried secrets true-crime

‘As I unknowingly sit so close to Tina’s grave, I am looking for answers, when all the while the answers are within this house.’

When beloved Cork woman Tina Satchwell vanished in 2017, her husband Richard made emotional media appeals, opened his home to journalists and insisted she had simply ‘upped and left’. But as months turned into years, nothing about Tina’s disappearance made sense, until eventually a cold-case review uncovered the terrible truth.

Drawing on Barry Cummins’s exclusive interviews and unprecedented access to the Satchwell home, this book reveals how Richard Satchwell’s carefully constructed facade concealed a calculated crime. From a claustrophobic house filled with secrets to the Garda breakthrough, Buried Secrets is a gripping true crime investigation and a personal reckoning from the journalist closest to the case.

Order your copy of Buried Secrets online here.

And read more on true-crime writing on Writing.ie here.

About the author

Barry Cummins’s latest book Buried Secrets: The Murder of Tina Satchwell and a Journalist’s Journey into Ireland’s Most Chilling Cold Case is out now. Barry is also the author of five other books: Missing, Lifers, Unsolved, Without Trace and Cold Cases.

Enjoyed this? Read related posts...

Subscribe to our newsletter

Get all of the latest from writing.ie delivered directly to your inbox.

Featured books